Saved to Favorites

(757) 565-2323Visit WebsiteMap & Directions5363 Richmond RdWilliamsburg, VA 23188Write a Review

Reviews

Hi there!
Rate this business!
What do you rate this business?First-classBetter than mostAbout what I expectedNot the worst...Disappointing
Click to Rate
HT
Holly T.

08/01/2018

Overall
Atmosphere
Food
Service

Sold me 8 month old beer, with bottle
Date of 1/1/18. Tasted funny and When asked, was told this is the bottle date, but after ordered 3rd, the date changed to 10/15/18...and tasted MuCH better!! emailed Miller Lite and confirmed it’s the sell by date, as I assumed. Very disappointed! But got a free glass! Just assume when you are paying this price point, the Miller Lite wouldn’t be 8 months old. Also food wasn’t great, but kids loved crab legs!

Review ImageReview ImageReview Image
JB
James B.

07/06/2018

Overall
Atmosphere
Food
Service

We really enjoyed this place and it was worth every penny we spent, will visit it again when in Williamsburg, Va, this is a must stop for great dining!

Euro K.
Edited: 10/09/2017
Overall
Lots to choose from!

There really is a lot to choose from, good quality food. The desserts are beautiful and yummy.

It can be a bit pricey for a 'buffet', but this isnt the typical 'buffet' food. You will easily spend $30 per person, but you'd spend that if you went to Red Lobster and had all the offerings you'd eat at the buffet.

Ya gotta try it!

KR
Kathy R.

06/28/2017

Overall
Atmosphere
Food
Service

Heard great things about this restaurant but, it is OK to the best. Food is not fresh and selection is limited.

CS
Charlie S.

07/03/2016

Overall
Atmosphere
Food
Service

I have been going to Capt Georges for years. The ambiance is awesome. The placement and variety of food is awesome. The quality of the food is so wonderful. The Crab Legs were plentiful, juicy, delicious and come with a special Captains sauce if you like or butter or margarine. There was seafood Norfolk, Seafood Imperial, hush puppies (corn bread), salad, many options of sauteed and fried fish, shrimp, spare ribs... so much more. The desserts were fantastic! They even serve ice cream from the bar as an addition to the buffet. I didn´t try it, but saw some come out, they looked yummy. I had quite an appetite going in and completely satisfied leaving. There was a line forming around the building when I left. There were many employees in the building to make my experience happy. The bathrooms were kept very clean. Great place! The price for the buffet is a tad steep, but I still felt like it was a value b/c of the crab legs and house made desserts... oh! the scallops, yum!

MC
Michele C.

11/05/2014

Overall

Love, love, love this restaurant...they have all my favorite foods and then some. The decor is lovely, old world charm and elegance, delicious, fresh and plentiful...highly recommend this place to anyone who loves seafood.

anonymous

07/28/2012

Provided by Superpages
Overall

We went to Captain Georges for my son's 16th birthday. I don't eat a lot of seafood but he loves the crab legs & he gets his moneys worth of crab legs. When I went through the buffet line they didn't have deviled crabs on the buffet & I was livid because that is the only seafood I really like except fried oysters. Our waiter Michael was so helpful. He went to the kitchen to talk to the chef & brought me what he thought I wanted & when that wasn't right , the chef himself came out to talk to me to see exactly what I was asking for. He told me they don't put them out until 5pm but he took it upon himself to go to the kitchen & fix me deviled crabs to keep me happy. I was very happy. I was very impressed that they would take the time to make sure I was satisfied. Thank you chef Edgar & Michael for making what could have been a very unhappy experience for me a great one. See you soon!

armyofone15r

05/21/2010

Overall
NOT WHAT I EXPECTED

Don't get me wrong. The foods is good. From fayetteville,nc on vacation, and decided to try Captain George's. The Problems: NO PRICES, SHOULD HAVE ASKED FIRST. For my wife and I to eat along with 2 sweet teas, our total came to $68.19 before a tip. Total $77.19 for a 30 min dinner. They even charge you for another buffet if you end up staying more than 2 hours there....RIP OFF? YOU TELL ME....MAYBE I'M JUST TOO CHEAP. Sorry E-4s in the Army don't make that kind of money. If we knew the price first, we would have went to McDonalds...

mvt964

12/03/2009

Overall
More seafood than you can eat

If you love seafood, this is the buffet for you. They have a great selection of fresh food and many yummy desserts.

mhughes994

09/20/2009

Provided by Superpages
Overall

i just returned from eating at Capt. Georges. I am on a gluten free diet, so I asked the manager what they had that was gluten free. She went to the Chef and he came out personally and showed me which foods on the buffet I could or could not eat. He even prepared some foods for me in the kitchen to prevent cross contamination. Needless to say, I was thoroughly impressed. The food was great and I will be back. Thank you Captain Georges.

Euro K.

04/18/2009

Provided by Superpages
Overall

I've only eaten at Captain Georges twice, both times its been very enjoyable due to the cleanliness, wide selection of fresh food, and beautiful dessert table. Staff is always friendly and helpful. A bit on the pricey side for me, but a real treat when I visit this seafood buffet.

nevfloyd

09/25/2006

Provided by Superpages
Overall
A local favorite of mine

see you soon. hopely around sept. 11,12,13,14, or 15. we love cap. geroge.

tschai

06/28/2006

Provided by Superpages
Overall
Good quality for the price

Anytime I want the best seafood buffet in the Hampton Roads area, I go here. The atmosphere is top notch and everything is clean. I go there just to load up on the great snow crab legs. They also have a variety of gourmet desserts.

Details

Phone: (757) 565-2323

Address: 5363 Richmond Rd, Williamsburg, VA 23188

Website: http://www.captaingeorges.com/

More Info

From The Boat to Your Plate-Caught Fresh Daily!

General Info
At Captain George's our food is prepared fresh daily on premises, everything from our homemade salads and dressings, to our secret seafood casserole recipes, to our freshly baked desserts and authentic Greek pastries. So come and enjoy the World Famous Captain George's Seafood Buffet, and we promise you won't leave hungry! Our all you can eat seafood buffet features over 70 items. The story of Captain George's is truly an American success story. From humble beginnings and an immigrant's dream of a better life for his family, a revolutionary concept in seafood dining was born. Debuting in the late 1970's, Captain George's has always provided guests with the ultimate dining experience serving premium seafood by an experienced staff in an upscale setting, and for this, people have been lining up at the doors since the beginning. Captain George's has grown from a single restaurant to four current locations with sights always set on future opportunities. We feel blessed by the success we continue to endure and love to extend our blessings to others in our community. We proudly support numerous local charities. Atmosphere: Casual
Email
BBB Rating
A+
BBB Rating and Accreditation information may be delayed up to a week.
Services/Products
Features: * Restaurant * Buffet Restaurant * Seafood Restaurant * Family Restaurant * All You Can Eat * Snow Crab Legs * Call to Request a Reservation
Payment method
visa, amex, discover, mastercard, cash, all major credit cards
Price Range
$$$
Languages
English, Greek
Other Emails

Categories
Other Information

Parking: Lot, Private

Wi-Fi: No

Bike Parking: Yes

Attire: Casual

Good For Family: Yes

Wheelchair Accessible: Yes

Cuisines: Buffets, Fine Dining, Caterers, Family Style, Breakfast, Brunch & Lunch, Seafood

Alcohol: Full Bar

Takes Reservations: Yes

Outdoor Seating: No

Good for Kids: Yes

People Also Viewed