Find a business

        HomeOHNew CarlisleRestaurantsPizza

        Pizza in New Carlisle, OH

        View all businesses that are OPEN 24 Hours
        Domino's Pizza - Pizza

        1. Domino's Pizza

        PizzaRestaurantsTake Out Restaurants
        (1)
        WebsiteView Menu
        Years in Business Icon
        64 Years
        in Business
        Amenities:
        Good for groups
        (937) 845-0202
        View all 21 Locations
        331 S Main St
        New Carlisle, OH 45344
        OPEN NOW

        the lady that took our order was very nice and very helpful. she was very pleasant to associate with"

        Order Online
        Casey's - Pizza

        2. Casey's

        PizzaRestaurants
        Website
        (937) 879-4687
        3387 S Dayton Lakeview Rd
        New Carlisle, OH 45344
        OPEN NOW

        From Business: Your New Carlisle, OH Casey's at 3387 S Dayton Lakeview Rd has the best pizza delivery and pickup featuring made-from-scratch dough, real mozzarella cheese, and…

        Karen's Pizzaria - Pizza

        3. Karen's Pizzaria

        PizzaRestaurants
        Years in Business Icon
        27 Years
        in Business
        (937) 857-9031
        106 N Main St
        New Carlisle, OH 45344
        CLOSED NOW
        Carmela's Pizzeria - Pizza

        4. Carmela's Pizzeria

        PizzaCaterersBars
        Website
        Years in Business Icon
        12 Years
        in Business
        Amenities:
        Offers outdoor seatingWheelchair accessibleHas WifiServes alcoholTakes reservations
        (937) 849-1112
        2015 S Dayton Lakeview Rd
        New Carlisle, OH 45344
        $
        OPEN NOW
        Cj's Pizza - Pizza

        5. Cj's Pizza

        Pizza
        (937) 845-9900
        6929 S Dayton Lakeview Rd
        New Carlisle, OH 45344
        Karen's Pizzaria - Pizza

        6. Karen's Pizzaria

        PizzaRestaurants
        (1)
        (937) 857-9031
        106 N Main St
        New Carlisle, OH 45344
        CLOSED NOW

        As an out of towner from st.louis I must say Karens pizza while not the same as back home, far eceeded my expectations. And the size ofd those ice cream cones will keep u…

        Papa Johns Pizza - Pizza

        7. Papa Johns Pizza

        PizzaRestaurantsTake Out Restaurants
        Website
        Years in Business Icon
        28 Years
        in Business
        (937) 846-1155
        View all 12 Locations
        410 N Main Street
        New Carlisle, OH 45344
        OPEN NOW

        From Business: For Papa Johns Pizza in New Carlisle, OH, the secret to success is much like the secret to making a better pizza - the more you put into it, the more you get out…

        Order Online
        Cassano's Pizza & Subs - Pizza

        8. Cassano's Pizza & Subs

        PizzaRestaurants
        (3)
        Website
        Amenities:
        Serves alcoholTakes reservations
        (937) 323-9238
        View all 15 Locations
        1525 S Dayton Lakeview Rd
        New Carlisle, OH 45344
        $
        OPEN NOW

        My son's first and last stop when coming up from Tarpon Springs!! It's salty and wonderful!"

        Order Online
        571 Grill and Draft House - American Restaurants

        9. 571 Grill and Draft House

        PizzaAmerican RestaurantsBar & Grills
        (1)
        WebsiteView Menu
        Years in Business Icon
        29 Years
        in Business
        Amenities:
        Wheelchair accessibleServes alcohol
        (937) 845-0089
        12389 Milton Carlisle Rd
        New Carlisle, OH 45344
        $$
        OPEN NOW

        Outstanding pizza and sandwiches served by very friendly staff. Atmosphere is early poverty with older tables and chairs."

        Casey's General Store - Convenience Stores

        10. Casey's General Store

        PizzaConvenience StoresGas Stations
        (1)
        Website
        (937) 879-4648
        View all 7 Locations
        3387 S Dayton Lakeview Rd
        New Carlisle, OH 45344
        OPEN NOW
        Regular
        $3.74
        Premium
        $4.44
        Diesel
        $4.00

        #Clean#Good Selection#Good Service"

        Pizza Plus - Beer & Ale

        11. Pizza Plus

        PizzaBeer & AleTake Out Restaurants
        (937) 845-1005
        101 Galewood Dr
        New Carlisle, OH 45344
        OPEN NOW
        Order Online
        Classic Pizza - Pizza

        12. Classic Pizza

        PizzaItalian RestaurantsTake Out Restaurants
        WebsiteView Menu
        Years in Business Icon
        48 Years
        in Business
        Amenities:
        Good for groupsServes alcohol
        (937) 233-7381
        7129 Taylorsville Rd
        Dayton, OH 45424
        $
        CLOSED NOW
        Order Online
        Pizza Hut - Pizza

        13. Pizza Hut

        PizzaTake Out RestaurantsFamily Style Restaurants
        (1)
        Website
        Years in Business Icon
        66 Years
        in Business
        Amenities:
        Good for groupsTakes reservationsGood for families
        (937) 878-7940
        View all 12 Locations
        428 N Broad St
        Fairborn, OH 45324
        $
        OPEN NOW

        They deliver to Enon, in case you were wondering."

        Order Online
        Cousin Vinny's Pizza - Pizza

        14. Cousin Vinny's Pizza

        PizzaRestaurants
        Website
        (937) 235-1500
        7742 Brandt Pike
        Dayton, OH 45424
        Little Italy Pizza - Pizza

        15. Little Italy Pizza

        PizzaItalian RestaurantsRestaurants
        (727) 522-2717
        1190 N Broad St
        Fairborn, OH 45324
        Hunt Brothers Pizza - Pizza

        16. Hunt Brothers Pizza

        Pizza
        Website
        (937) 877-3056
        4455 Gibson Dr
        Tipp City, OH 45371
        Donatos Pizzeria - Pizza

        17. Donatos Pizzeria

        PizzaRestaurantsTake Out Restaurants
        WebsiteView Menu
        Years in Business Icon
        30 Years
        in Business
        (937) 879-7000
        View all 14 Locations
        21 N Broad St
        Fairborn, OH 45324
        $$
        OPEN NOW
        Order Online
        Pizza Partners Of Ohio Limited - Pizza

        18. Pizza Partners Of Ohio Limited

        PizzaRestaurants
        Years in Business Icon
        15 Years
        in Business
        Amenities:
        Wheelchair accessible
        (937) 236-2424
        7631 Troy Pike
        Dayton, OH 45424
        OPEN NOW
        Rapid Fired Pizza - Pizza

        19. Rapid Fired Pizza

        PizzaRestaurants
        WebsiteView Menu
        Years in Business Icon
        3 Years
        in Business
        (937) 951-3901
        6315 Brandt Pike
        Huber Heights, OH 45424
        $
        OPEN NOW
        Larosa's Pizzeria - Pizza

        20. Larosa's Pizzeria

        PizzaRestaurants
        (513) 347-1111
        7375 Troy Pike
        Dayton, OH 45424
        D J's Pizza Alley - Pizza

        22. D J's Pizza Alley

        PizzaTake Out RestaurantsRestaurants
        (1)
        Years in Business Icon
        31 Years
        in Business
        (937) 667-2297
        18 S 2nd St
        Tipp City, OH 45371
        CLOSED NOW

        Best pizza in Tipp City. I don't know about how good it is compaired to another, because I don't get any other pizza! Oh yea! Very friendly people. My daughter & I were walking…

        The Hampton Grill - Pizza

        23. The Hampton Grill

        PizzaRestaurants
        Years in Business Icon
        18 Years
        in Business
        (937) 964-8927
        45 E Clark St
        North Hampton, OH 45349
        $
        OPEN NOW
        Order Online
        CiCi's Pizza - Pizza

        24. CiCi's Pizza

        PizzaTake Out RestaurantsRestaurants
        (3)
        Website
        Years in Business Icon
        39 Years
        in Business
        (937) 236-2424
        View all 2 Locations
        7631 Troy Pike
        Dayton, OH 45424
        $
        OPEN NOW

        Back with another pizza review. Today it is CiCi's Pizza. We have only given a single 1 star review and this is it. The price is GREAT! It is an all you can eat pizza buffet,…

        Little York Pizza - Pizza

        25. Little York Pizza

        PizzaRestaurantsTaverns
        (3)
        Website
        Years in Business Icon
        36 Years
        in Business
        BBB Rating Icon
        Accredited
        Business
        Amenities:
        Offers outdoor seatingWheelchair accessibleHas WifiServes alcoholTakes reservations
        (937) 890-6700
        4120 Little York Rd
        Dayton, OH 45414
        $$
        OPEN NOW

        I love there food it was good"

        Marco's Pizza - Pizza

        26. Marco's Pizza

        PizzaTake Out RestaurantsPasta
        (4)
        WebsiteView Menu
        Years in Business Icon
        18 Years
        in Business
        (937) 503-8100
        View all 5 Locations
        5001 Brandt Pike
        Huber Heights, OH 45424
        $$
        OPEN NOW

        hogies and momma are very very good food!"

        Order Online
        Hickory Inn - Pizza

        27. Hickory Inn

        PizzaAmerican RestaurantsTake Out Restaurants
        (6)
        Website
        Years in Business Icon
        77 Years
        in Business
        Amenities:
        Good for groupsServes alcohol
        (937) 323-1779
        652 N Limestone St
        Springfield, OH 45503
        $$
        CLOSED NOW

        My favorite restaurant! The menu is extensive and the owners are insistent on using only the very best quality products. I love the steaks (especially the ribeye), prime rib…

        Bada Bing! Pizzeria - Pizza

        28. Bada Bing! Pizzeria

        PizzaSandwich ShopsItalian Restaurants
        (3)
        Amenities:
        Wheelchair accessibleServes alcoholTakes reservations
        (937) 390-1300
        40 N Fountain Ave
        Springfield, OH 45502
        $
        OPEN NOW

        Great pizza and garlic knots aren't bad either. Friendly and clean locally owned."

        Cousin Vinny's Pizza - Pizza

        29. Cousin Vinny's Pizza

        PizzaRestaurants
        (1)
        WebsiteView Menu
        Years in Business Icon
        16 Years
        in Business
        Amenities:
        Wheelchair accessible
        (937) 318-1000
        1080 Kauffman Ave
        Fairborn, OH 45324
        OPEN NOW

        the have the best pizza in town"

        Jet's Pizza - Pizza

        30. Jet's Pizza

        PizzaTake Out RestaurantsSandwich Shops
        (3)
        Website
        (937) 431-1111
        View all 3 Locations
        2418 Esquire Dr
        Beavercreek, OH 45431
        $
        OPEN NOW

        LOVE the thick crust! Great $5 lunch special too!"

        About Search Results

        YP - The Real Yellow PagesSM - helps you find the right local businesses to meet your specific needs. Search results are sorted by a combination of factors to give you a set of choices in response to your search criteria. These factors are similar to those you might use to determine which business to select from a local Yellow Pages directory, including proximity to where you are searching, expertise in the specific services or products you need, and comprehensive business information to help evaluate a business's suitability for you. “Preferred” listings, or those with featured website buttons, indicate YP advertisers who directly provide information about their businesses to help consumers make more informed buying decisions. YP advertisers receive higher placement in the default ordering of search results and may appear in sponsored listings on the top, side, or bottom of the search results page.

        Places Near New Carlisle, OH with Pizza

        More Types of Restaurants in New Carlisle