Find a business

        HomeNYMonticelloRestaurantsPizza

        Pizza in Monticello, NY

        Albella Restaurant - Pizza

        1. Albella Restaurant

        PizzaItalian RestaurantsFamily Style Restaurants
        (4)
        WebsiteView Menu
        Amenities:
        Offers outdoor seatingWheelchair accessibleHas WifiServes alcoholTakes reservations
        (845) 794-8866
        50 Jefferson St
        Monticello, NY 12701
        $$
        CLOSED NOW

        A great place to eat. I took my wife out for Valentine's Day and the food and service was wonderful as usual. I had my mind on getting the Salmon Albella's but decided to get…

        Order Online
        Colosseo Family Restaurant & Pizzeria - Pizza

        2. Colosseo Family Restaurant & Pizzeria

        PizzaFamily Style RestaurantsRestaurants
        (1)
        Website
        Years in Business Icon
        24 Years
        in Business
        Amenities:
        Wheelchair accessibleHas WifiServes alcoholTakes reservations
        (845) 791-1255
        11 Raceway Rd
        Monticello, NY 12701
        $$
        CLOSED NOW

        Best buffalo chicken pie.... the best I️ ever had"

        Broadway Pizza - Pizza

        3. Broadway Pizza

        PizzaRestaurants
        WebsiteView Menu
        (845) 791-7200
        462 Broadway
        Monticello, NY 12701
        $$
        CLOSED NOW
        Order Online
        Nature's Delight - Pizza

        4. Nature's Delight

        PizzaRestaurants
        Website
        (845) 796-0270
        554 W Broadway
        Monticello, NY 12701
        OPEN NOW
        Pizza Hut - Pizza

        5. Pizza Hut

        PizzaRestaurantsTake Out Restaurants
        Website
        Years in Business Icon
        27 Years
        in Business
        Amenities:
        Good for groupsGood for families
        (845) 796-1616
        View all 3 Locations
        352 E Broadway
        Monticello, NY 12701
        CLOSED NOW
        Kosher Pizza Palace - Pizza

        6. Kosher Pizza Palace

        PizzaRestaurants
        Website
        Years in Business Icon
        54 Years
        in Business
        (845) 794-3420
        250 E Broadway
        Monticello, NY 12701
        OPEN NOW
        Order Online
        Brother Bruno Pizza Restaurant - Pizza

        7. Brother Bruno Pizza Restaurant

        PizzaCaterersRestaurants
        (2)
        Website
        Years in Business Icon
        19 Years
        in Business
        Amenities:
        Serves alcohol
        (845) 791-4600
        4050 State Route 42
        Monticello, NY 12701
        $$
        CLOSED NOW

        Best pizza in Sullivan County IMHO. Excellent food over all. Nice people too!"

        Papa Luke's Pizzeria - Pizza

        8. Papa Luke's Pizzeria

        PizzaItalian RestaurantsRestaurants
        View Menu
        Years in Business Icon
        12 Years
        in Business
        Amenities:
        Offers outdoor seatingWheelchair accessibleServes alcohol
        (845) 791-7272
        42 Kitz Rd
        Monticello, NY 12701
        $
        CLOSED NOW
        Siena's Pizza - Pizza

        9. Siena's Pizza

        PizzaItalian RestaurantsRestaurants
        Website
        Years in Business Icon
        76 Years
        in Business
        Amenities:
        Has WifiServes alcoholTakes reservations
        (845) 791-7662
        10 Mountain Mall Plz
        Monticello, NY 12701
        CLOSED NOW
        Giovanni's Subs & Pizzeria - Pizza

        10. Giovanni's Subs & Pizzeria

        PizzaDelicatessensRestaurants
        Years in Business Icon
        46 Years
        in Business
        Amenities:
        Wheelchair accessibleServes alcohol
        (845) 794-8668
        4457 State Route 42
        Monticello, NY 12701
        $
        CLOSED NOW
        Kosher Pizza Palace - Pizza

        11. Kosher Pizza Palace

        PizzaRestaurants
        (845) 794-3420
        66 Broadway
        Monticello, NY 12701
        Pizza D'pie - Pizza

        12. Pizza D'pie

        PizzaRestaurants
        Years in Business Icon
        19 Years
        in Business
        (845) 791-8140
        4682 State Route 42
        Kiamesha Lake, NY 12751
        CLOSED NOW
        Loca Pannini Pizza I - Pizza

        13. Loca Pannini Pizza I

        PizzaRestaurants
        (3)
        Years in Business Icon
        19 Years
        in Business
        (845) 436-8500
        5108 State Route 42
        South Fallsburg, NY 12779
        CLOSED NOW

        The food is awesome and they deliver on time! Only restaurant other than New China to deliver to Sullivan County Community College. Had already called 24 restaurants before i…

        Forage Pizza - Pizza

        14. Forage Pizza

        PizzaTake Out RestaurantsRestaurants
        Website
        (845) 707-4620
        2846 State Route 42
        Forestburgh, NY 12777
        CLOSED NOW
        Benji & Jake's - Pizza

        15. Benji & Jake's

        PizzaAmerican RestaurantsCaterers
        Website
        Years in Business Icon
        15 Years
        in Business
        Amenities:
        Offers outdoor seatingWheelchair accessibleHas WifiServes alcohol
        (845) 583-4031
        5 Horseshoe Lake Rd
        Kauneonga Lake, NY 12749
        $$
        CLOSED NOW
        Delicious Pizza - Pizza

        16. Delicious Pizza

        PizzaRestaurants
        (1)
        Amenities:
        Wheelchair accessible
        (845) 434-5845
        5202 Main St
        South Fallsburg, NY 12779
        CLOSED NOW
        Brooklyn Brick Oven Pizza - Pizza

        17. Brooklyn Brick Oven Pizza

        PizzaCaterersRestaurants
        Years in Business Icon
        23 Years
        in Business
        Amenities:
        Offers outdoor seatingWheelchair accessibleHas WifiServes alcohol
        (845) 434-7427
        1146 State Route 52
        Loch Sheldrake, NY 12759
        CLOSED NOW
        Peppino's - Pizza

        18. Peppino's

        PizzaCaterersItalian Restaurants
        Website
        Years in Business Icon
        9 Years
        in Business
        Amenities:
        Offers outdoor seatingServes alcoholTakes reservations
        (845) 887-6767

        Serving the
        Monticello Area

        $$
        CLOSED NOW

        From Business: Italian Cuisine • Full Bar • Specialty Cocktails • Great Wine Selection • Nightly Signature Dishes • Catering • Seasonal Outside Seating • Decadent Desserts •…

        Sprinkles Kosher Pizza - Pizza

        19. Sprinkles Kosher Pizza

        PizzaRestaurants
        (1)
        Website
        Years in Business Icon
        25 Years
        in Business
        (845) 434-0200
        5670 State Route 42
        Fallsburg, NY 12733
        CLOSED NOW

        Love the pizza, Jeremy should be nominated as the best Pizza maker in the US! Mr Feller provides friendly service to all his customers!"

        Marco's Pizza - Pizza

        20. Marco's Pizza

        PizzaPastaFamily Style Restaurants
        (1)
        View Menu
        (845) 693-4847
        1501 County Road 52
        Fallsburg, NY 12733
        $$
        CLOSED NOW

        The website listed above is incorrect. This pizza place has no website. The address is incorrect too, should be 1501 State Rt 52 Loch Sheldrake, NY 12759. HOWEVER... The pizza…

        Pizza the Rock - Pizza

        21. Pizza the Rock

        PizzaTake Out RestaurantsRestaurants
        Website
        Amenities:
        Offers outdoor seatingWheelchair accessibleGood for groupsHas Wifi
        (845) 796-3900
        345 Rock Hill Dr
        Rock Hill, NY 12775
        $
        CLOSED NOW
        Napoli's Pizzeria - Pizza

        22. Napoli's Pizzeria

        PizzaTake Out RestaurantsCaterers
        Years in Business Icon
        33 Years
        in Business
        (845) 292-8888
        2574 State Route 52
        Liberty, NY 12754
        CLOSED NOW
        Danny Steakout & Pizza - Pizza

        23. Danny Steakout & Pizza

        PizzaCaterersRestaurants
        Years in Business Icon
        8 Years
        in Business
        Amenities:
        Offers outdoor seatingWheelchair accessible
        (845) 292-0007
        1869 State Route 52
        Liberty, NY 12754
        CLOSED NOW
        Pancho's Pizza & Wings - Pizza

        24. Pancho's Pizza & Wings

        PizzaItalian RestaurantsRestaurants
        View Menu
        (845) 747-9686
        25 Sullivan Ave
        Liberty, NY 12754
        CLOSED NOW
        Pancho's Pizza & Wings - Pizza

        25. Pancho's Pizza & Wings

        Pizza
        Website
        (845) 747-9686
        25 Sullivan Ave Liberty Mall
        Liberty, NY 12754
        CLOSED NOW
        Charlies Pizzeria - Pizza

        26. Charlies Pizzeria

        PizzaItalian RestaurantsRestaurants
        Website
        (845) 292-9951
        77 N Main St
        Liberty, NY 12754
        CLOSED NOW
        Uccellini - Pizza

        27. Uccellini

        Pizza
        (845) 888-9993
        725 Sullivan St
        Wurtsboro, NY 12790
        Giovanni's Inn - Pizza

        28. Giovanni's Inn

        PizzaItalian RestaurantsRestaurants
        Website
        Years in Business Icon
        33 Years
        in Business
        Amenities:
        Offers outdoor seatingServes alcohol
        (845) 888-2099
        2433 State Route 209
        Wurtsboro, NY 12790
        $$
        CLOSED NOW
        Mohican Inn - Pizza

        29. Mohican Inn

        PizzaRestaurants
        (845) 858-8305
        367 Mohican Lake Rd
        Glen Spey, NY 12737
        CLOSED NOW
        About Search Results

        YP - The Real Yellow PagesSM - helps you find the right local businesses to meet your specific needs. Search results are sorted by a combination of factors to give you a set of choices in response to your search criteria. These factors are similar to those you might use to determine which business to select from a local Yellow Pages directory, including proximity to where you are searching, expertise in the specific services or products you need, and comprehensive business information to help evaluate a business's suitability for you. “Preferred” listings, or those with featured website buttons, indicate YP advertisers who directly provide information about their businesses to help consumers make more informed buying decisions. YP advertisers receive higher placement in the default ordering of search results and may appear in sponsored listings on the top, side, or bottom of the search results page.

        Places Near Monticello, NY with Pizza

        More Types of Restaurants in Monticello