In My Book: Food
Add To Mybook

Tasty Pizza

5101 Mayfield Rd, Cleveland, OH 44124
(9)
$$
Italian
Closed Now
Today

11:00 am - 10:00 pm

Tomorrow

11:00 am - 10:00 pm

(440) 449-1252DirectionsMap
Photo Gallery
1 of 2
  • Photo by Infousa
    Added on 08/26/2014
  • Photo by Citysearch
    Added on 05/02/2014

MORE INFO

REVIEWS(9)

  • Delicious, Authentic Italian Food!
    by  on 01/04/2011

    Don't let the American-sounding name fool you. Compola’s Tasty’s Pizza is absolutely amazing and authentic Italian! Great service from what seems like a family run business (not sure if it is). It is worth spending a dollar or 2 more than the chain places on pizza to get some great quality food and support the “little guy.” They also have other food like calzones and pasta and you can eat inside. So good!

  • Not the same as it used to be
    by  on 03/23/2010

    This pizza is still good, but it's definetly not the same as it used to be. It's different almost everytime I get it. Some times it's cooked well, but other times it's undercooked, the cheese isn't cooked enough and the crust will be doughy. I am not sure what happened but quality control needs to be put in place to offer a more consistent product. I hope Tasty's reads this because I have been a customer for over 20 years.

  • Great Pizza !
    by  on 07/21/2009

    Best Pizza In Town ! The best sauce, crust plus the best variety of drinks and beer ! Sports photos. Everyone treats you like family ! After having dinner here ... who would want to go anywhere else for pizza ! Mario Georgio Santa Barbara, Ca.

  • I love this pizza place. Grea...
    by  on 01/14/2008

    I love this pizza place. Great place to eat in or carry out. Quaint old time pizza joint. Pizza's and salads are exceptional. You won't be disappointed. Wish they delivered.

  • Best pizza in Ohio
    by  on 06/08/2005

    Best pizza in Ohio by far. The only better pizza is in NY.

  • Best in Cleveland!
    by  on 12/12/2003

    Great staff, awesome pizza, killer ambiance. The pizza is unreal! Best in NE Ohio. You will NOT be disappointed.

  • Best Pizza...Period!
    by  on 11/05/2003

    This is the best pizza you can buy around here. It is always fresh tasting and never greasy like a lot of other pizzas around here. Plus, you can go in there with a gang of kids and nobody complains. A family operation that treats its customers like family. You help yourself to drinks and then just tell them what you had and they charge you appropriately after your meal when you pay for your pizza. I won't buy a pizza anywhere around here but from this place!

  • The BEST of the BEST Pizza
    by  on 07/17/2003

    It is the BEST pizza I have had in this town and all across the USA. The sauce has a very nice taste and the crust is just perfect. The food is very affordable and it is a great place to take the entire family. The owner Joe is a great guy and he is up on all the latest sporting news. A must to try in homemade food.

MORE STUFF NEAR YOU

Open in YP app »

Just a moment...